Now Available:

line

Featured Resources:

line

Newsletter

Email Address:


line

Ask the Expert

Have a question for our resident expert? Email your questions to Rebecca.

« Data Ransom Story: Crooks Targeting Small Businesses and Individuals | Main | Email Smack Down: Morgan Stanley Charged by NASD with Purposefully Withholding Emails »

PCAOB Formally Proposes New Auditing Standard for Section 404 of SOX

Yesterday the SEC issued a press release regarding a Public Company Accounting Oversight Board (PCAOB) proposal for a new auditing standard for Section 404 of the Sarbanes-Oxley (SOX) Act. The goal of the proposal will be to strengthen investor protection while getting rid of what is referenced as the "unduly expensive and inefficient auditing standard under Section 404."

"Washington, D.C., Dec. 19, 2006 - The Public Company Accounting Oversight Board (PCAOB) today voted to propose a new auditing standard for the audits of registrants' internal control over financial reporting under Section 404 of the Sarbanes-Oxley Act, which, if adopted by the PCAOB and approved by the Commission, would supersede the PCAOB's Auditing Standard No. 2.

Christopher Cox, Chairman, U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission, said, "The PCAOB's proposal to repeal the unduly expensive and inefficient auditing standard under Section 404 of Sarbanes-Oxley — and to replace that standard with one that strengthens investor protection by refocusing resources on what truly matters to the integrity of financial statements — is an exceptionally positive step for both investors and for America's capital markets. The SEC and the PCAOB have worked together to ensure that the Commission's proposed interpretative guidance for management and the PCAOB's proposed new auditing standard are mutually reinforcing. Together, these proposals should significantly improve the implementation of Section 404, making it more efficient and effective. Smaller public companies should particularly benefit from the scalability built into these proposals. We look forward to considering the public comments on these proposals."

Conrad Hewitt, Chief Accountant, U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission, added, "The PCAOB's proposed auditing standard is a welcome development, and we look forward to reviewing it carefully. We encourage companies, audit firms, investors and any other interested parties to comment on both the PCAOB's proposed auditing standard and the Commission's proposed interpretative guidance for management during the proposals' overlapping comment periods. We will consider all of these comments carefully before making any recommendations to the Commission."

So, what is the PCAOB proposal? Take a look here to see all 131 pages of it.

The beginning of the proposal states:

"As described below, the proposals are designed primarily to – • Focus the audit on the matters most important to internal control by, among other things, directing the auditor's testing to the most important controls; emphasizing the importance of risk assessment; revising the definitions of significant deficiency and material weakness, as well as the "strong indicators" of a material weakness; and clarifying the role of materiality, including interim materiality, in the audit; • Eliminate unnecessary procedures by, among other things, removing the requirement to evaluate management's process; permitting consideration of knowledge obtained during previous audits; refocusing the multi-location testing requirements on risk rather than coverage; removing barriers to using the work of others; and recalibrating the walkthrough requirement; • Scale the audit for smaller companies by, among other things, directing the auditor to tailor the audit to reflect the attributes of smaller, less complex companies; and • Simplify the requirements by, among other things, reducing detail and specificity; better reflecting the sequential flow of an audit of internal control; and improving readability."
This certainly seems common sense, doesn't it?

It probably warms the hearts of those chilled by jumping through all the audit hoops of SOX over the past couple of years to comply with Section 404 to see that changes of this sort are likely soon.

It is notable that this proposal would require consideration of applicable controls and review work that have already occurred to test and evaluate the controls. This alone should significantly impact and reduce the SOX compliance audit duration for most organizations.

Bottom line, it appears a stronger emphasis on risk-based controls specific to each organization. This is a positive step in aligning this regulation more closely with similar types of risk-based control requirements in other federal regulations such as HIPAA and GLBA.

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.realtime-itcompliance.com/type/mt-tb.cgi/264

Post a comment

(All comments are approved by site leader before appearing here. Thanks for commenting!)

line

Rebecca Herold's Bio:

Rebecca Herold,CISSP, CIPP, CISM, CISA, FLMI, has been providing information security, privacy and regulatory assistance and services to organizations from a wide range of industries for over 18 years. Rebecca was instrumental in building the information security and privacy program while at Principal Financial Group, which was awarded the CSI Information Security Program of the Year Award in 1998. IT Security ranked Rebecca as one of the top 59 IT security influencers, and Computerworld put Rebecca their list of the 25 top privacy experts and on their list of the 9 best privacy consulting firms. Rebecca has been CPO for two consulting organizations, and has had her own information privacy, security and compliance business since 2004. Rebecca has written chapters for several books, dozens of articles, and has been writing a monthly privacy column for the CSI Alert newsletter since the beginning of 2001, and is working on her 11th book. Some of her other books include The Privacy Papers, Managing an Information Security and Privacy Awareness and Training Program, The Definitive Guide to Security Inside the Perimeter (Realtime Publishers), The Shortcut Guide to Improving IT Service Support through ITIL (Realtime Publishers), and The Practical Guide to HIPAA Privacy and Security Compliance. In addition, Rebecca is the leader of The Realtime IT Compliance Community where she posts to her IT Compliance weblog. You can contact Rebecca at: rebecca_herold@realtimepublishers.net.