Common InfoSec & Privacy Training Mistakes
I've been reviewing some of the information security and privacy training and awareness content for some organizations; some large and some small. Most of the training is ineffective...
When information security and/or privacy incidents happen, too many organizations, and otherwise smart professionals, say that information security and privacy training doesn't work and isn't worth the time, when in fact the problem is that the training they are providing is bad and ineffective, and usually awareness communications are non-existent!
Step back and consider that everyone does NOT learn and understand in the exact same way. Organizations must think about the communications used within training and awareness efforts.
Human nature closely parallels mother nature...
I like to run around my lake next to the hay field. Not only is it good exercise, it also gives me some good thinking time. As I run, I hear the constant croaking of the bullfrog and the intermittent but regular chirps of the leopard frog. When I'm close to the water, the sandpipers start squeaking at me from where they stand and continue until I leave the water's edge. There are three red-winged blackbird nests right next to my running path. When I approach each, the parent birds start screaming at me and flying around me, trying to distract me from their nest. As soon as I am a little distance away, they stop their tirade. These are four different creatures with four different and distinct ways of communicating. The bullfrog constantly drones with his loud message, the leopard frogs emphasize their chirping message regularly, the sandpipers start sounding their warnings when I approach, and consistently squeak while I'm in their area. The red-winged blackbirds scream only when I am very close.
They remind me of how organizations do their awareness and training activities: The frogs sing out to anyone within earshot, such as many organizations do who are sending awareness messages for anyone to read or notice. The blackbirds targeted their messages specifically at me, much like training efforts that are targeted at specific groups. As with most organizations, these messages are basically the same, regardless of who might be within hearing range.
Indiscriminate announcements such as these are bound to be ineffective with some types of passersby. This consistent and unvarying type of communicating is often the same move that organizations make when it comes to information security and privacy training and awareness activities; they send the same messages in the same way to widely diverse groups of audiences. This is just one of the mistakes organizations make when launching training and awareness programs.
Tailor training content and awareness communications to be specific to your organization, and provide different content to your different target groups, based upon their job responsibilities.
I will provide much more about infosec and privacy training and awareness mistakes, along with more in-depth details, in blog posts to come!
Have any questions? Let me know and I'll try to address them in future posts.

Email This!
Digg it!
Del.icio.us
Reddit!
Newsvine
Comments
One approach to security awareness activities I am aware of and which apparently works is to make the activities *personally relevant* to the workforce.
One large organisation in the UK did this by providing training/information sessions for staff related to personal/home computing - i.e. how to install/configure AV software and why it was necessary, how to use a personal firewall, how to spot a phishing e-mail and so forth. From here, they then turned the focus of the training to the company's aims and objectives with the result that staff understood why security policies and controls were necessary and why they were implemented.
I'm not sure how prevalent this approach is in the States (it's not really prevalent in the UK), but would be interested to hear your views.
Oh, and your views on Marcus Ranum's "6 Dumbest Ideas in Computer Security" (http://www.ranum.com/security/computer_security/editorials/dumb/), specifically number 5 ("Educating Users") would also be of interest!
Posted by: fatbloke | June 1, 2009 7:43 PM
Thanks for your comment, fatbloke! (Gosh, I feel really rude saying that!)
I wholeheartedly agree, and I've been preaching this for over a couple of decades. My training and awareness tools, contents and products are all built upon making information understandable, and relateable, to the personnel.
And yes; I have some definite views about #5 of the 6 so-called ideas!
I will elaborate upon all this on a blog post in a day or two!
Rebecca
Posted by: Rebecca Herold
|
June 2, 2009 1:27 PM